VibeMathedMath problems solved with AI

Property R∞R_\infty for Artin groups (AIM Problem 8.6): the irreducible spherical case

A group GG has property R∞R_\infty if every automorphism φ∈Aut⁡(G)\varphi \in \operatorname{Aut}(G) has infinitely many twisted conjugacy classes, where xx and yy are φ\varphi-twisted conjugate if y=zxφ(z)−1y = z x \varphi(z)^{-1} for some z∈Gz \in G. Problem 8.6 of the AIM problem list Geometry and topology of Artin groups asks: which Artin groups have property R∞R_\infty? A remark by Ignat Soroko on the list records the property as known for the spherical types AnA_n and BnB_n (n≥2n \ge 2), D4D_4 and I2(m)I_2(m) (m≥3m \ge 3), for the Euclidean types A~n\tilde A_n and C~n\tilde C_n and for certain right-angled Artin groups, and as failing for abelian right-angled Artin groups.

Result
Proved(see note)
Status
Partial result
AI contribution
AI-discovered
Method
Argument
Field
Geometric group theory; twisted conjugacy in Artin groups
Posed by
AIM Problem List, Geometry and topology of Artin groups, Problem 8.6
Year posed
—
Years open
—
Solved
2026-11-10
Model
Claude Opus 5.5 (Claude Code); GPT-6 Astra (Codex)
Vendor
Anthropic; OpenAI
Collaborators
Jason Davies
Verification
Unreviewed
Publication
Preprint
Significance
12 / 100
Disclosed cost
—
Wikipedia
No dedicated article

What was actually shown

Theorem A: every irreducible Artin group of spherical type and rank at least two has property R∞R_\infty. Types AnA_n, BnB_n, D4D_4, I2(m)I_2(m) (Calvez and Soroko) and DnD_n, n≥6n \ge 6 (Soroko and Vaskou) were known, and the paper notes that D5D_5 follows from a 2026 lemma of Paris and Soroko, so the new cases are E6E_6, E7E_7, E8E_8, F4F_4, H3H_3 and H4H_4. Theorem B classifies R∞R_\infty for the crystallographic quotients ΓX=A(X)/[P,P]\Gamma_X = A(X)/[P,P], PP the pure subgroup: it holds in rank at least three, and for X=I2(m)X = I_2(m) exactly when 4∣m4 \mid m, or mm is odd and 3∣m3 \mid m. Proposition C: A(I2(5))/[P,P]A(I_2(5))/[P,P] has an automorphism with Reidemeister number 18, so the quotient does not inherit R∞R_\infty. The proof relies on Cohen and Paris's computer-assisted theorem that PP is characteristic, which the authors did not re-run. Non-spherical Artin groups are not covered, so Problem 8.6 stays open in general.

What the AI did

Per the paper's AI transparency statement and its Hexagon provenance statement, Claude Opus 5.5 (through Claude Code) and GPT-6-Astra (through Codex) developed the mathematical arguments, the exact Python certificates, the Lean formalisation and the manuscript, under the author's direction. Hexagon labels the paper as primarily AI-generated text with human understanding of no parts, and the provenance statement says no human expert has independently reviewed the work. The author takes responsibility for the content and for the accuracy of the disclosure. The repository's own audit file is described as an AI audit.

Verification

No independent mathematician has checked this yet; Hexagon's label says a human understands no parts of the paper. Unreviewed on this site's ladder, lowered from the submitted Lean-checked, because Lean does not prove the headline outright. Checked here on 19 November 2026: Hexagon paper 2611.00278v1 (introduction, Theorems A and B, Proposition C, Appendix C, the AI declaration) and the archived AIM page with Problem 8.6. The repository jasondavies/spherical-artin-rinf was read at commit ab2165a, the one the paper pins (67 Lean files, about 8,500 lines, Lean 4.35.0). A grep found no sorry, axiom, admit, native_decide, implemented_by, extern or unsafe. Two statements were read. artinQuotient_exists_reidemeister_eighteen states Proposition C for the presented quotient A(I2(5))/[P,P]A(I_2(5))/[P,P] with no hypotheses. artin_E8_R_infty_FH, and its six siblings for D5D_5, E6E_6, E7E_7, F4F_4, H3H_3, H4H_4, concludes that every automorphism of the presented Artin group has infinite Reidemeister number, but takes four cited results as hypotheses: finiteness of the Coxeter group, Cohen and Paris's theorem that the pure subgroup is characteristic, the rank of its abelianisation, and the Franzsen-Howlett decomposition of Coxeter automorphisms (H3H_3 and F4F_4 also have versions without the last). Theorem B, on which the paper's own proof of Theorem A rests, is not formalised. Not rebuilt here, and the repository has no CI. The Python certificates were not run.

Sources

Submitted by MellowGander562 on

Changelog2 changes

Discussion