Tao's question on the relations of a Lie subalgebra
Let be the real Lie algebra generated by () subject to and . Let be the subalgebra generated by the and the . It satisfies , and, by the Jacobi identity, . Are these a generating set of relations for , or are there further relations among the and ? In a comment YCor also asked whether the , , freely generate a Lie subalgebra of .
- Result
- Proved(see note)
- Status
- Candidate (review pending)
- AI contribution
- AI-assisted
- Method
- Argument
- Field
- Lie algebras; presentations
- Posed by
- Terry Tao, MathOverflow question 464808 (24 February 2024)
- Year posed
- 2024
- Years open
- 2y
- Solved
- 2026-11-16
- Model
- OpenAI Codex; Anthropic Claude (versions not recorded)
- Vendor
- OpenAI; Anthropic
- Collaborators
- Qiyuan Ma
- Verification
- Unreviewed
- Publication
- Preprint
- Significance
- 10 / 100
- Disclosed cost
- —
- Wikipedia
- No dedicated article
What was actually shown
Theorem 1.1: yes. The three families of relations, with the Lie algebra axioms, generate all relations of , over any field of characteristic 0. The proof polarises to multilinear components, presents the ideal generated by the , bounds an associated graded algebra for an 'excess' filtration, and closes with a dimension count from the Hilbert series of (Eulerian numbers). By-products: is a semidirect product of a free Lie algebra and an abelian one, and the , , freely generate a free Lie subalgebra, answering YCor's question. The paper says the Hilbert series is equivalent to known results on Losev-Manin spaces (Losev-Manin 2000; Dotsenko-Shadrin-Tamaroff 2023) and claims as new only the answer and the freeness statement, which its literature search did not find elsewhere.
What the AI did
From the paper's acknowledgements and the Hexagon provenance statement: AI assistance (Codex from OpenAI and Claude from Anthropic, versions not recorded) was used in the literature search, in designing and running the computational experiments, in writing the accompanying verification code, and in drafting the manuscript. Hexagon labels the paper 'Primarily AI-generated text', human understanding 'some parts'; the author reports that some parts, but not all, have been checked and understood, without saying which, and takes sole responsibility. AI is not an author.
Verification
Read by this site on 19 November 2026: the Hexagon record and PDF (hexagon 2611.00542v1, 17 pages) and Tao's MathOverflow question with all its comments, fetched through the Stack Exchange API. The statement matches the question as posed (the paper works over any field of characteristic 0, the question over the reals), and the question had no answers. A sanity computation written here, independent of the author's code, built the multilinear components of the enveloping algebras by linear algebra and found the map from the presented algebra injective in every multilinear degree (dimensions 2, 5, 18, 77 on both sides), and the dimensions of there (5, 16, 65, 326) consistent with the paper's count for . That supports the theorem in low degree; it does not check the proof. The 17-page argument was not refereed, the author's code archive was not located or run, and by the Hexagon label the author has checked only some parts. No expert reaction was found. Candidate until someone independent reads the proof in public.
Sources
Submitted by RustyDingo867 on